On Manhaj, Dyeing One’s Hair and Nasheeds
Does Manhaj Fall Under the Category of ʿAqīdah or Aḥkām?
Questioner: There are two questions here. The first is does methodology [manhaj] fall under the category of creed [ʿaqīdah] or rulings [aḥkām]?
Al-Albaani: The terminology used which has emerged and continues to emerge especially during this era, does not concern us when answering this question. Rather, I say as he ﷺ said in the ḥadīth of the Khutbatul-Ḥājjah, which I mentioned earlier, where he ﷺ said, “And the best guidance is the guidance of Muhammad ﷺ,” and in another narration, “The best way is the way of Muhammad ﷺ.”
So the guidance of the Prophet ﷺ must be taken in its entirety. We do not differentiate between the end and the means, because the means lead to the end prescribed by Allaah, the Mighty and Majestic. If there are means that the Messenger ﷺ clarified to the Ummah and ordered or encouraged them to adopt, it is not [then] permissible for us to invent new means in their place and this remains true even if these means are generally permissible in principle [mubāḥ] but [then] we [go and] adopt them as a method to invite the Ummah to Islaam in general, or to the specific details of Islaam brought by the Prophet ﷺ.
We know that new concepts have emerged in this era which people have adopted to bring others closer to Islam. And they have taken these means as if they are the ends, adhering to them with the claim that they bring them closer to Allaah.
For example, they adopt modern games with which the lands of disbelief have been afflicted—for those disbelievers are the primary intended subjects of the words of Allaah, the Blessed and Most High, “they have taken this faith ˹of Islam˺ as mere play and amusement and are deluded by ˹their˺ worldly life.” [6:70] Some Muslims have followed their path, finding appeal in these new games imported from the lands of disbelief, whose people have no religion but amusement and play. And so certain individuals belonging to Islamic parties have adopted these as a means to bring the youth closer to an Islaam from which they have, unfortunately, become entirely distanced.
This was not from the guidance of the Prophet ﷺ. His guidance was to invite the youth, the elders, and all people to worship Allaah, the Blessed and Most High, alone without any partners, and to remind them that there is another life: either an everlasting bliss or a blazing Hellfire, depending on whether their deeds were righteous or wicked. As the Most High says, “As for the one who is charitable, mindful ˹of Allaah˺, and ˹firmly˺ believes in the finest reward, We will facilitate for them the Way of Ease [92:5-7], meaning Paradise. “And as for the one who is stingy, indifferent ˹to Allaah˺, and ˹staunchly˺ denies the finest reward, We will facilitate for them the path of hardship,” [92:8-10] meaning Hell. This is how the Prophet ﷺ used to remind his companions of Paradise and Hell, using it as a means to draw them closer to the worship of Allaah, the Blessed and Most High.
Today, certain methods have been adopted by some people in imitation of those disbelievers who the Prophet ﷺ warned us against imitating in many authentic ḥadīths that are well-known to all those present, inshā Allaah. Among them is his saying ﷺ, as recorded in Ṣaḥīḥ Al-Bukhārī, “You will follow the same path as was trodden by those before you, inch by inch and step by step, so much so that if they were to enter into the hole of a lizard, you would follow them in that too.” We said, “Allaah’s Messenger, do you mean the Jews and Christians?” He said, “Who else?” And he ﷺ said in an authentic ḥadīth found in Musnad Aḥmad and elsewhere, “I have been sent just before the Hour with the sword so that Allaah Alone may be worshipped without any partners. My provision was placed under the shadow of my spear, and humiliation and lowliness were decreed for those who oppose my command. And whoever imitates a people is one of them.”
At the same time as he forbade imitating the disbelievers, the Prophet ﷺ urged the Muslims toward something even higher and more noble, which is his saying, “The Jews and Christians do not dye [their hair], so differ from them,” meaning their grey hair, they do not dye their hair, so differ from them.
This is how the Prophet ﷺ paid attention to the Muslims not imitating the disbelievers, but, in fact, to also avoid sharing traits with them even in things they both have no choice but to share in [i.e., old age etc.]—the Prophet ﷺ ordered them to differentiate themselves by dyeing their hair—something which they cannot help but share with them in. Greying hair is the Way of Allaah [that He has decreed] in His creation, there is no difference in it between a Muslim and a disbeliever. Everyone who reaches a certain age will experience greying. Therefore, the Prophet ﷺ ordered the Muslim, when greying begins to appear, to dye it because the disbelieving Jews and Christians do not dye their hair. He said, “So differ from them.”
The ḥadīths ordering us to differ from the polytheists are very, very numerous and I have collected a good number of them in my book The Ḥijāb of the Muslim Woman, so whoever wishes to explore this topic further can refer to it. The point is that at the same time as forbidding imitating them, the Prophet ﷺ added to that the encouragement to actively differ from the disbeliever. Differing is broader than merely avoiding imitation. A Muslim does not intentionally imitate a disbeliever when, for example, he turns grey, because this is the creation of Allaah. However, they can actively differ from the disbeliever by dyeing their hair. This is why he ﷺ said “The Jews and Christians do not dye [their hair], so differ from them.”
If the Prophet’s ﷺ eagerness to encourage Muslims to differ from the polytheists reached this level, how can it be permissible for some Muslims today to adopt the very methods used by disbelievers to attract people to mosques? It has even reached the point where some have brought pictures into the mosques, and even musical instruments in some countries, under the guise of ‘softening the hearts’ of Muslims.
Even more catastrophic and bitter than this in terms of deceiving the masses are the methods they have spread and made popular and recorded on many tapes: what they call ‘Islamic Nashīds.’ Satan, the accursed, initially led them to this means by embellishing their vocal delivery and setting some of what they call “Islamic nashīds” to melodies using the meters/rhythms used by immoral singers.
This is how they began spreading these so-called ‘Islamic’ nashīds. Then, Satan dragged them further, moving them from this first act of disobedience to another that is even more hideous: they began beating tambourines and drums during what they call Islamic nashīds.
Then he took them further until they introduced other musical instruments that [even] the immoral people before them did not know—instruments invented by European disbelievers. They brought these nashīds and these instruments into the houses of Allaah, the Blessed and Most High, along with pictures, videos, and similar means, claiming that they are meant to attract people to the obedience and worship of Allaah in His houses.
They have fallen into exactly what the disbelievers of old fell into before, where some of the Prophet’s ﷺ wives upon returning from Abyssinia mentioned a church they had seen there to the Messenger ﷺ, noting the pictures and images inside it. He ﷺ said, “When a righteous man among them died, they would build a place of worship over his grave and make those pictures on it. They are the most evil of creation in the sight of Allaah, the Blessed and Most High.”
The mosques of today have become very similar to Christian churches in terms of their ornamentation, their decoration, and the singing of what they call religious nashīds within them. My greatest fear is that a day will come when immodestly dressed women are permitted to enter mosques, exactly as Christians do in churches.
We ask Allaah, the Mighty and Majestic, to protect us from the evil of newly invented matters.
This is what I am able to offer in answer to this question. We ask Allaah to guide the Muslims back to their religion in the light of the Book and the Sunnah, and upon the way of the righteous predecessors.
Al-Huda wan-Noor, 805.
